At the end, there is an email address; we invite you to send us your comments. If you need a custom essay or research paper on this topic please use our writing services. Juveniles can also be placed in adult jails for largely practical reasons—for example, if they have been arrested in a regional area where there is no juvenile detention facility.
Below, a few of the arguments posited by both sides of the juvenile crime debate. The term juveniles—often used interchangeably with youth and young people—refers to individuals legislatively defined as such in any given jurisdiction.
Or does he maintain some trappings of childhood, despite the gravity of his actions? These are the questions plaguing the American legal system today, as the violent acts of juvenile offenders continue to make headlines. A young person released from juvenile prison is far less likely to commit a crime than someone coming out of an adult facility.
The adult courts would be a better venue for this case because the punishments are more severe than juvenile courts. Historically, children and adults in Western countries were subject to the same criminal justice processes and penalties.
He then went downstairs and shot his younger siblings and father to death. A key argument in opposition to detaining Adult as essay juvenile offender should treated in adult jails is that juveniles Adult as essay juvenile offender should treated immature and inexperienced and should therefore be treated with more leniency than adult offenders.
The fundamental question is, are children capable of understanding the consequences of their actions? They have a powerful ally: It is therefore more cost-effective to detain juveniles in adult jails.
These laws transfer the juvenile cases to adult criminal courts. As such, those who oppose placing juveniles in adult jails argue that treatment and rehabilitation programs such as cognitive-behavioral therapies and drug rehabilitation should be tried before juveniles are incarcerated.
A key shift in contemporary penal policy has been the recognition that juveniles require criminal justice responses that are separate from those for adults, and the consequent division of Western justice systems into separate systems for adults and juveniles.
In these cases, some have argued that the rights of the community should override those of juvenile offenders and that juveniles should be incarcerated in adult jails. Some states, however, will consider and year-olds for the death penalty. Further, it has been argued that staff in adult jails do not have the training or skills to manage juvenile offenders.
If juvenile offenders are rational actors who weigh the risks and rewards of committing crime, then it follows that giving courts the ability to sentence juveniles to adult jails should act as a deterrent to juveniles.
While juveniles are held legally responsible for criminal conduct, they are usually processed via a separate justice system designed to deal with young people the juvenile justice or youth justice system.
All but five states allow children of any age charged with murder to be tried as adults. Let us know what you think. Crime statistics suggest that in many jurisdictions, juvenile offending is increasing. YES The end result of a heinous crime remains the same, no matter who commits it.
If juvenile crime is increasing in both quantity and seriousness, and current efforts to curb it are ineffective, then it follows that the community is at increased risk from juvenile crime and needs to be protected. No matter how tough your topic and requirements are, you can count on us.
In some jurisdictions, juveniles can be tried in court as adults, and thus subject to the same sentences as adults, including incarceration in an adult jail. Juveniles can be incarcerated in adult jails for a range of reasons.
Are we seeing a drop because children are thinking more carefully about their crimes, knowing they could receive adult sentences?
The cost of juvenile detention facilities is typically much higher than that of adult facilities. If you commit a terrible crime, you will spend a considerable part of your life in jail.
Pay only for approved parts School Essay Sample: It has been argued, therefore, that juvenile offenders should be treated differently than adults and be provided with developmentally appropriate responses from the justice system.
While not all countries are signatories to these frameworks, those opposed to detaining juveniles in adult jails argue that signatories have an obligation to meet the principles they embody.
Further, there is typically a lower staff-to-inmate ratio in juvenile detention facilities than in adult jails, as the state has an enhanced duty of care to ensure the well-being of juveniles in detention. There are two requirements that must be met before the cases can be transferred: In case you need help with your law essay, or any other type of academic paper, you are welcome to contact our service.Juvenile Justice System: Juveniles Should Be Treated the Same as an Adult Criminal - There are many reasons against why offenders of a crime that are under eighteen should not be treated the same as an offender of a crime that is 18 or older.
The purpose juveniles should go to the juvenile court because it is a treatment and guidance rather than punishment (Cliff Notes). By placing juveniles offenders in a place that was made for adults can take a toile on them. Although juveniles may know right from wrong, immaturity should be a reason for them not to be tried as adults.
Should Juveniles be tried as adults in the Justice System, or should they have to endure the same punishment. Delinquency in the Juvenile Justice system was really low in the 90’s.
Crimes committed now by young offenders are getting high since the 90’s. However, if a juvenile is given a sentence as an adult, they should serve the remainder of their juvenile life in a juvenile detention facility before being transferred to an adult prison.
Any young offender who commits a felony should be tried as an adult.3/5(8). Should the U.S.
justice system treat juvenile violent offenders as adults? YES. The end result of a heinous crime remains the same, no matter who commits it. Our justice system depends upon holding perpetrators responsible for their actions. Everyday juveniles are being tried in adult criminal court.
Between and forty-four states and the District of Colombia passed laws facilitating the transfer of juveniles to the adult system/5(10).Download